Why we still need Agent Carter

NOT SPOILER FREE

This month saw season two of ABC/Marvel’s Agent Carter come to an end, and despite critical acclaim and a fanbase that cares deeply for the show and its characters, its dwindling ratings have once again left its future in doubt. The show follows SSR Agent Peggy Carter (portaryed by the excellent Hayley Atwell) and what she gets up to in post-WW2, post-Captain America: The First Avenger New York City, and in the second season, Los Angeles. It’s a fun show that adds depth to the ever-expanding MCU, and as we all know Peg ends up founding S.H.I.E.L.D. and living to the ripe old age of 90-something, so why not explore Peggy’s life as society continued to change and evolve so quickly? There are so many compelling reasons for ABC to keep Agent Carter on the air, but here are just a few:

agent carter
via Hulu

1) Women, women everywhere!

A potential issue with superhero shows, or shows within a superhero universe, is that even women-fronted titles can still be somewhat of a sausage-fest. This is not the case in Agent Carter. The show consistently passes the Bechdel test, with all of the women coming from all walks of life, with varying strengths and weaknesses. The show depicts strong female bonds in the form of Peggy and Angie (and just all the girls of The Griffith in season one) and Peggy and Ana Jarvis. Two of the shows main villains, Dottie Underwood (the original Black Widow, portrayed by Bridget Regan) and Whitney Frost (AKA Madame Masque, who didn’t even wear a mask in the end, portrayed by Wynn Everett), are two of the most compelling and complex villains I’ve ever seen on television. In a society where women are seen (and often depicted) as one-dimensional and either perfect angels or devilish succubi, it’s amazing to see women, regardless of their moral compass, have particular strengths and weaknesses, and to be able to interact in a plethora of different settings all under one title. And it’s still something television in 2016 is lacking.

2) The writing is incredible.

Agent Carter is one of the best-written shows on television today. I already mentioned the women, but the men in the show are written just as well! Season two’s arc with Jarvis and Ana after she got shot was emotional, Jason Wilkes struggles with the zero matter and makes some difficult choices throughout, and even Jack Thompson seemed to grow, just a little bit. The wonderful character-building and development aside, the show’s plot throughout each season is made up of varying storylines and arcs that all come together nicely – its engaging and allows for a whole spectrum of emotion.

3) Imagine Peggy in the 1960s. Or 70s.

Peggy’s long life means there’s so much potential to see her kicking ass throughout different decades of the 1900s. Peggy was a fighter and would have definitely been a part of the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s, and would have obviously been at the forefront of the feminist movement throughout the 1970s. Agent Carter  in other decades of the 20th century would be a stellar opportunity for exploring social issues and making social commentary – something the show has already done in the forms of Peggy and Jason – the show has proved it is willing to provide such commentary, why not take it one step further?

4) The queer potential!

Cartinelli, AKA Peggy Carter and Angie Martinelli, were, and still are, one of the shows most popular ships, with both Hayley Atwell and Lyndsy Fonseca showing their support for it – the two have a lot of chemistry, and while I adore them as friends, it would also be great to have them get together in order to explore homosexuality and/or bisexuality in 1940s America. Even Dottie, who wore Peggy’s lipsick and chloroform kissed her, has so much potential as a queer character, with some elements of subtext once her sleeper agent identity is revealed. It seems Peggy Carter has chemistry with just about anyone, regardless of gender, and I think it would be a great addition to a show which already represents complex women so excellently.

agent carter i know my value
via Yahoo!

5) “I know my value” – the Peggy Carter effect

In the season one finale, Valediction, Peggy tells Souza “I know my value, anyone else’s opinion doesn’t really matter” after Jack Thompson takes all the credit for bringing down Leviathan and Fenhoff. This single quote speaks volumes about Peg as a character, and sparked countless fan arts and tattoos as well as a revolution of self-love and self-acceptance among women and girls. Peggy doesn’t need a man’s, or anyone else’s approval. That’s a good message to send to young girls in an age where they’re constantly told image is everything. And any show or film or any other kind of media that promotes the message that the only opinion about you or your life that truly matters is your own, is something that is worth showing.

So there you have it – five reasons why Agent Carter is still very much wanted and needed, and this doesn’t even get into the possibility of tie-ins or other links to the MCU/Marvel universe. Agent Carter is a show that profoundly effects those who are invested, and a fanbase that is dedicated and moved by what is put on screen is one that is willing to support you throughout – provided you execute it right – making it a beneficial asset on both sides. The world needs more Peggy, there is no doubt about it.

It’s time to stop burying our gays

Recently, an episode of The 100 aired where (spoilers), high-profile lesbian character, Commander Lexa, was killed off. Like any popular television show, fans of Lexa, and the Clexa ship, kicked off. While I’ve never actually seen an episode of The 100, it is clear that the death of Lexa, a lesbian character who holds a lot of power in the eyes of her people, holds a lot more weight than the average fictional death. And it’s obvious why.

TV Tropes describes the Bury Your Gays trope as (emphasis mine):

Often, especially in older works (to the extent that they are found in older works, of course), gay characters just aren’t allowed happy endings. Even if they do end up having some kind of relationship, at least one half of the couple, often the one who was more aggressive in pursuing a relationship, thus “perverting” the other one, has to die at the end. Of course, it can also happen to gay characters who aren’t in relationships, particularly if they’re psycho lesbians or depraved homosexuals.

[…] Also known as Dead Lesbian Syndrome. This trope can also be seen as a head-on collision between Sex Is Evil andAll Gays Are Promiscuous.

So here’s the thing – characters die all the time. That’s normal. However, even in 2016 an overwhelming majority of characters within film and television are straight, while much of the LGBTQ representation that is available is mostly white gay men. While as a society we have (for the most part) moved on from explicitly killing a queer character for being queer, the few queer characters that do appear are killed off at a much more alarming rate than their straight counterparts, suggesting that Western society isn’t as on board with homosexuality – or anything that isn’t heterosexuality – as it likes to think.

“But SO MANY MORE straight characters die so it doesn’t matter!!” Okay, I see your point, and raise you this – there are many straight characters that die – but there are so many more that live, because straight characters are so much more common. However LGBT characters, particularly lesbians, are fewer and farther between. So when of them dies, especially in very dubious circumstances (I’m looking at you, Orphan Black), especially as part of a society that reinforces the idea that straight is the default, the ideal (nothing is made in a vacuum), it reinforces the very much alive and kicking notion that LGBTQ+ people are not worthy of happiness, or are destined to die. Which can have some pretty severe knock-on effects.

It is pretty much common knowledge by now that members of the LGBTQ+ community already face higher rates of mental health issues, including anxiety, depression and suicide, than our straight counterparts.So much so that Stonewall, one of the leading LGBTQ+ charities in the UK, have a huge portion of their website dedicated to LGBT mental health and wellbeing. Media that markets itself on positive LGBT representation that then allows its queer characters to be the main subject of 80%+ of its angst, maybe even killing them, reinforces the idea that queer people are not meant to live happy lives; that they will die young and that all their efforts are for nothing. It is very easy for straight people who have never experienced such things to say “it’s just a TV show/film/webseries/book/etc., its not real life and it means nothing” but for so many people within the LGBT community, it is our lives. And when there’s so little representation of yourself on screen, its so hard to not put every part of your heart and soul into it. Shows that pride themselves on such positive representation of queer communities, such as The 100 and Orphan Black should know this, and should already be aware of such tropes that surround queer characters that, if shown on screen after talking about how “gay friendly” they are, will have a colossal impact on their audiences.

It is not enough for queer people, especially queer women, to just be seen on screen anymore. Any representation in 2016 that is worth having should be good, positive representation that shows queer characters being happy and not being killed by stray bullets. We need to be shown and portrayed and written with the same respect that straight men and women are, otherwise we will be stuck eternally disappointed, treated badly and adding our favourite queer ladies to an already-long, ever growing list of buried gay women. And that is unacceptable.

Shadowhunters so far

NOT SPOILER FREE

Shadowhunters is a relatively new TV show based on Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments book series and wider Shadowhunters book universe. As someone who read and loved the first few books of the series when I was younger (City of Glass was supposed to be the final book, and by the time City of Fallen Angels came out, I had moved on), and was bitterly disappointed by that God-awful movie a few years back, I was very interested in watching it and hoping it would be miles better than the film. Twelve year old Mia didn’t care for how good quality the writing was, so I couldn’t tell you now as a 21 year old adult how great Cassandra Clare is as a writer, but I do remember how much I loved the characters, the story and the universe they were in. It was exciting and new and I really, really wanted to be Clary. Or Isabelle. So to see a poorly-executed film version of a series I loved so much as a child was heartbreaking. Hearing about the TV show being in production reignited the small flame of hope that it would be done properly, and seeing it come to Netflix in January was super exciting.

shadowhunters
Shadowhunters promotional image. Via fashionstyle.

For those unfamiliar with the series, 18-year-old Clary Fray discovers she is a Shadowhunter (a half human, half angel hybrid whom are usually tasked with killing demons) after witnessing what she believes to be a regular (i.e., non-paranormal) murder, and then her mother’s disappearance. The first book, City of Bones, and the TV show so far depict her coming into this new world and the hunt for both her mother and the much-coveted Mortal Cup.

Six episodes of Shadowhunters have aired so far, and although at the beginning the show came off as very cheesy and shallow (but still enjoyable: just because something is either or both of these things doesn’t make it bad by default), with some special effects that didn’t quite fit, it’s really come into it’s own in the last couple of weeks. While Luke’s alliances at the beginning of the show are ambiguous, we discover he’s actually been on Clary’s side all along, and despite not finding the Jace-Clary-Simon love triangle plot not being as cute or even interesting as I did when I was twelve, I love that it is often shown in parallel to Magnus and Alec. And that Magnus’ bisexuality is explicitly addressed! And he isn’t shown as a promiscuous immortal being with no feelings! That is worth something. One thing that these later episodes have been lacking is the friendship between Clary and Isabelle that began to develop at the beginning, but I have faith we will see more of them as the show goes on.

Overall, if you like cheesy fantasy shows that allow for real feeling and emotion as it gets deeper into the story and the character’s histories, Shadowhunters is great for that. Even if it’s not your thing, it’s still better than the film. And that is worth something, at least.